Insights · Research

Rankings get you named. Until the client describes a problem.

A client calls a law firm about a problem. The practice group is the firm's name for it. AI starts from the problem too.

Jacob Shamis
Jacob ShamisFounder and CEO · November 2026Last updated

What AI checks before it recommends anyone

Jimmy Park and Tobias Peschke tracked more than 659,000 AI answers to buying questions. Before ChatGPT recommends anyone, it checks the same few things: who is asking, what they need done, how they compare options, and what proof exists. What they need done came up in 92.5% of answers.

Their study did not cover law firms, so we looked at ours.

What we asked

We audited 17 US law firms. We asked ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google's AI answers 308 questions a client might ask, across 43 practice groups, and read all 1,176 answers.

Some asked for the best firms by practice:

Best-firm question

"Which law firms are the best for complex commercial litigation in New York?"

Others described a problem:

Problem question

"Our largest customer ended a supply contract two years early and still owes us $18 million. Which firms handle a case like this?"

What changed when the question changed

When the question asked for firms by practice, the firm we audited was named in 35% of answers. AI leaned on ranking sites like Chambers, Legal 500 or Best Lawyers, which showed up in 70% of those answers.

When the question described the problem, the same firm was named in only 16% of answers. The ranking sites mostly dropped out. They appeared in 26%.

Share of AI answers, by the kind of question asked

The audited firm is named

Best-firm questions35%
Problem questions16%

Ranking sites show up in the answer

Chambers, Legal 500, Best Lawyers and others

Best-firm questions70%
Problem questions26%
Share of AI answers by question type
MeasureBest-firm questionsProblem questions
The audited firm is named35%16%
Ranking sites show up in the answer70%26%
Share of answers. Selectio audits of 17 US law firms, Aug to Nov 2026: 308 questions, 1,176 answers.

We saw the same drop at all 17 firms and on every AI tool we tested.

Where AI went instead

On problem questions, AI leaned on law firm websites instead. 17 of the 25 sites it cited most were law firm websites. Government and court sites showed up in 27% of answers, up from 5%.

On the problem questions where AI did name the firm, it linked to that firm's own website 8 times out of 10. The 6 firms whose own pages AI used most were named in 39% of problem answers. The other 11 firms were named in 3%.

What this means for your firm

Rankings still help the client who knows what kind of lawyer they need. For the client who starts with the problem, the firms that get named are the ones whose own pages answer it.

Three things to do

  1. Ask ChatGPT the question your best client asked you last year, in their words. See who it names.
  2. List the problems clients bring you, practice by practice.
  3. Give each problem a page that shows your lawyers have handled it.

See what AI says about your firm

Run the free AI visibility check and see how the engines answer for your firm today.

See what AI says about your firm →

Sources

  • The Determinants Manifesto, Opascope and Loud & Lexis, Nov 2026.
  • Selectio audits of 17 US law firms, Aug to Nov 2026: 43 practice groups, 308 questions, 1,176 answers from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.

Related reading.